that one of Bullâs cousins out in Montana had a potential lead on Malcolm Carter. Though I was reluctant to be away from Millie Jo for the week that weâd planned to be gone, I would be lying through and through if I didnât acknowledge the intensity of my elation at the prospect of all that incredible time alone with Mathias. We kept calling it our âpre-honeymoon.â
âJuly fifth,â I reminded Mom, taking a long swallow of my cold beer.
âItâs great out that way. The mountains will draw you in, watch out,â Blythe teased. And then to Mom, âYou donât think heâs cold, do you?â
The boatâs motion stirred the still air, creating a rushing breeze that was a little chilly. Mom bent and nuzzled Matthewâs little cheek, making him squirm and giggle. She assured Blythe, âHeâs not cold, sweetheart. Heâs right up against you.â
âYou two out to look for that stash of gold that Bullâs crazy Grandpa Grafton raved on about in the old days?â Dodge asked me then.
Mom and Aunt Jilly both groaned at this question.
âHere, hon,â Aunt Ellen said, handing me a plate. As Dodge was busy driving the pontoon, Aunt Ellen was taking care of grill duty.
âThanks,â I told her, and then to Dodge, âWhat do you mean?â
âBull hasnât told you that story yet?â Aunt Ellen asked me. âIâm stunned.â
Dodge assumed his storyteller voice, the one we had all listened to a thousand times sitting around the fire, and said, âI heard the tale for the first time when I was just a boy. My pa was still alive then and he knew Grafton Carter well. Grafton was Paâs second cousin, once-removed, on the Riley Miller sideâ¦â
âNo, for the love, donât get into family connections,â Jilly scolded, though not without affection. âWeâll never get to the point!â
Dodge draped his wrists over the top of the big steering wheel, gazing into the middle distance, seemingly serious. This was unusual enough that I sat straighter to listen. He continued, âGrafton swore that there was a legend in the Carter family about a letter scribbled with a map, with directions to a stolen haul of gold from sometime back in the 1870s, if I do recall. Not that the Carters would ever admit to thievery, being a prideful lot, so sure as shit there was a good reason for the theft. That is, if the story had any truth to it. Somewheres out west was all Grafton knew.â
âDoes it have anything to do with Malcolm?â I asked, rapt with attention. The old, fading picture of Malcolm and his horse, Aces, was still in the top drawer of my nightstand. I had found it over two years ago; fate, I was certain, as the discovery had led me to White Oaks and eventually Mathias.
âThat I donât know,â Dodge said, speculation ripe in his tone. âAsk Bull. From everything I know, Malcolm was the boy who disappeared. I donât know if heâs connected to Graftonâs story or not.â
âThereâs no record of him after the telegram from 1876,â I affirmed, heart increasing in speed at the thought.
âI just felt a jolt when you said that,â Aunt Jilly said intently. âThere may be no record, but he lived beyond 1876, Iâm certain.â
âWeâve searched through everything that Bull could find in the attic at White Oaks,â I said, goosebumps shivering over my arms at Aunt Jillyâs words. I believed whole-heartedly in her ânotions,â which she had once explained to me as striking her with all the unexpectedness of lightning on an otherwise clear summer night. Usually they were precognitive, and when she told you something, youâd do well to heed it. âBut thereâs more, I know thereâs so much more. Thatâs what weâre hoping to find in July,â I added, catching my ring between the index finger